Lane had left the group in early January 2011 and Creighton left in April 2012 in order to pursue a solo career.
The judges, after a suggestion by Cowell, put them together in a band, qualifying for the Groups category. As a result of the public vote, they were put in bottom three and had to sing in the final showdown on 17 October, after Storm Lee polled the least amount of votes and was eliminated.Belle Amie were an English pop girl group based in London, consisting of members Esther Campbell, Jessica Batist, Clarissa White, and Sophia Wardman.They were formed during the seventh series of The X Factor in 2010.The band originally consisted of Campbell, Wardman, Rebecca Creighton and Geneva Lane.Their debut single, "Girls Up", was released in August 2011.In the first week of live shows, they sang "Airplanes" by B.o. They sang "Big Girls Don't Cry" and were saved when all three independent judges Walsh, Minogue and Cole opted for them to stay and eliminate Diva Fever instead, leaving no need for their mentor Cowell to vote either way.
In the third week, they sang "I'll Stand by You", in which they progressed to the fourth week, where they performed "Venus".
However, that night they ended up in the bottom two with Katie Waissel, and sang "Breakaway" in the final showdown.
After the judges votes became deadlocked, the public vote showed that Belle Amie had the least amount of votes and were eliminated.
A week later, the group performed at G-A-Y, along with Diana Vickers.
On the future as a band, Geneva said "'We want to keep ourselves busy, we don’t want to fade. We are definitely staying together and are going to move in together at some point, we’re looking already.
We want to experiment and really find ourselves, because we still feel that we need to find our identity, so this is going to be good for us.